Close Menu
Slideshow

The Global Sparkling Masters 2019: results in full

Our annual Sparkling Masters gives the judges the chance to hone in on which fizzes are hitting the spot in terms of taste, quality and value. This year, they were particularly impressed with the quality of crémants from the Loire.

Of all the categories in the wine business, it’s sparkling where the competition appears to be the most intense. Whether its between regions, or countries, there seems to be a near-ceaseless urge to prove that one fizz-making area is better than another, with producers pitted against each other in a range of tastings.
It’s why we tend to see headlines such as ‘English fizz beats Champagne in landmark tasting’, ‘Aussie sparkling voted best in the world’, or ‘Discount crémant better than fizz costing five times the price’, and so on.
While we take no issue with the reporting, it is worth considering the nature of such comparisons. How are these tastings being conducted? And who are the judges? After all, with an issue as emotive as sparkling wine quality, it’s vital that such events employ professionals, and the organisers do their best to minimise any bias.

Repeated sampling

With such thoughts in mind, it is important to state that db’s tastings see samples judged ‘blind’, although the entries are organised loosely according to style, and presented in given price bands. As for the tasters, they must be Masters of Wine, or Master Sommeliers, and where buyers or writers are enlisted, it is because they are specialists in the category being judged. Not only that, but every entry is scored then discussed, ensuring that each taster’s result is scrutinised by a peer, and every wine is properly assessed. This may be a drawn-out process, often involving repeated sampling of the same wine, but it yields credible results, which are then shared in full here, and in the magazine too, with the addition of analysis and opinion.
In short, with the Global Sparkling Masters, you can trust the results, which have been arrived at via a rigorous tasting process, one conducted purely to assess quality, not to yield a particular outcome. So, the conclusions we draw from a day’s sampling are based on the nature of the samples submitted, and yes, sometimes the results do yield a sensational outcome, but that is by accident, not design.
So, what were the headline findings from this year’s Global Sparkling Masters? Initially, the tasting highlighted the broad sweep of places now making delicious traditional-method sparkling wine. We had Golds from bottle-fermented fizz-producing areas from the Loire to the Western Cape, Hungary to Hampshire, and New Zealand to Austria. In other words, if you thought the source of great sparkling wine was either France or Spain – or just Champagne or Cava – be prepared for a surprise as you scan the origins of our medallists this year.
Also, for those who believe that Prosecco is the go-to for little more simple-tasting fizz, then think again. When this tank-method sparkling was tasted blind against similarly priced bottled-fermented products, it did just as well or better, in many cases. This was true at higher prices too, with, for example, Andreola’s Dirupo Brut Prosecco picking up a Gold in the £30-£50 sparkling wine flight, along with a traditional-method fizz from Austria (Schlumberger Wein) and one from England (Louis Pommery).
We were also impressed by the quality-to-price ratio among the sparkling wines from two producers in particular: South Africa’s Pongracz and Hungary’s Törley. But if one were to pick out the source of the best-value fizz on the market based on this year’s tasting, it would have to be the Loire. As you can see in the tables, two names stood out for their crémants – the name for bottle-fermented fizz from France that hails from outside Champagne. These were Bouvet Ladubay and Langlois Château. The most keenly priced Gold-medal-winning fizz of the competition was the £11 Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference Crémant de Loire Brut, which is made by Bouvet Ladubay for the supermarket. The sparkling wine garnered a high score for its combination of richness and refreshment, combining the cleansing flavours of apple and chalk, with more creamy characters, and a touch of honey-coated toast, which provided added interest.

Quality fizz

Such was the quality of this fizz for the money, the judges agreed that they would now be looking closely at crémant when selecting wines for their own events.
Bearing in mind the creep upwards of Champagne prices in this decade, it’s becoming more common for consumers to seek out a cheaper alternative to this famous fizz when pouring a sparkling wine for big, celebratory events.
And, if one goes to other aspirational traditional-method winemaking regions, such as Franciacorta in Italy, or the southern counties of England, such as Kent and Sussex, you’ll find brilliant quality, but also prices that are similar, if not higher, than an equivalent Brut NV from Champagne.

Delicious options

So it was exciting to find in this year’s Global Sparkling Masters that there are delicious options of creamy, gently toasty fizz on the market today at roughly half the price of grandes marques Champagnes.
Some of these were from the Loire, but there were a wide range of other sources providing an exciting set of choices for the open-minded sparkling wine lover. This is an extremely competitive area of the wine business, but like all areas of the drinks industry, it pays to look broadly in the search for quality and value.
Over the following pages you can see all the medallists from this year’s competition, as well as comments from the judges (who are pictured below), and more information about the Global Sparkling Masters, including how to enter. 
The judges (left to right): Michelle Cherutti-Kowal MW, Simon Field MW, Patricia Stefanowicz MW, Ennio Pucciarelli, Antony Moss MW, Andrea Briccarello, Patrick Schmitt MW

White Sparkling Brut

Company Product Name Region Country Vintage Medal
Under £10
Villa Sandi Villa Sandi Asolo Prosecco Superiore DOCG Brut Biodiversity Veneto Italy NV Silver
Lidl Ireland Arestel Cava Brut Catalonia Spain NV Silver
Valdo Spumanti Valdo Garda DOC Spumante Brut Veneto Italy NV Silver
Viña Luis Felipe Edwards VADO Colchagua Costa Chile NV Silver
Cave de Ribeauvillé Crémant Organic Alsace France NV Silver
Alma Wines AMBO SECCO ™ Pinot Noir Brut Lombardia Italy NV Bronze
Barton & Guestier B&G Chardonnay Brut Ardèche France NV Bronze
Patriarche Veuve de Vernay Brut Burgundy France NV Bronze
Törley Sparkling Wine Cellar François President Brut Etyek-Buda Hungary 2015 Bronze
Cantina Montelliana Montelliana Prosecco DOC Frizzante Veneto Italy 2018 Bronze
£10-£15
Bouvet Ladubay Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference Crémant De Loire Brut Loire Valley France NV Gold
Masottina “Contrada Granda” Brut Rive di Ogliano Conegliano Valdobbiadene DOCG Prosecco Superiore Veneto Italy 2017 Silver
Villa Sandi Villa Sandi Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Brut Millesimato Veneto Italy 2018 Silver
Bodegas Faustino Cava Faustino Brut Rioja Spain NV Silver
Sektkellerei Szigeti Cava Faustino Brut Burgenland Austria 2017 Silver
Pernod Ricard Winemakers Spain Gran Campo Viejo Cava Brut Reserva Cava Spain NV Silver
Bouvet Ladubay Saumur Brut Blanc Loire Valley France NV Silver
Paul Mas Prima Perla Chardonnay Grande Réserve Languedoc France NV Silver
Marqués de Cáceres Cava Brut Penedès DO Cava Spain NV Silver
Bouvet Ladubay Bouvet Saphir Saumur Brut Loire Valley France 2016 Silver
Paul Mas Cote Mas Frisante Languedoc France 2017 Bronze
Freixenet Copestick Freixenet Cordon Negro Cava Brut Catalonia Spain NV Bronze
Kavaklıdere Wines Altın Köpük Cappadocia Turkey 2017 Bronze
Sektkellerei Szigeti GmbH Szigeti Welschriesling Brut g.U. Klassik Burgenland Austria 2016 Bronze
Badischer Winzerkeller Peter Steger Konzept Chardonnay Brut Baden Germany 2014 Bronze
£15-£20
Pongracz Pongracz Blanc de Blancs Western Cape South Africa NV Gold
MA SPA Vallate Prosecco DOC Brut Veneto Italy NV Silver
3GP FIOL Veneto Italy NV Silver
Cave de Ribeauvillé Crémant Grande Cuvée Alsace France NV Silver
Cavit Altemasi Trentodoc Millesimato Brut Trentino Italy 2015 Silver
Lidl Ireland Comte de Senneval Champagne Brut Champagne France NV Silver
Skull X Skull X Italy Italy 2018 Silver
Langlois-Chateau Crémant de Loire Brut Loire Valley France 2008 Silver
Kavaklıdere Wines Cotes d’Avanos Cappadocia Turkey 2015 Silver
SCAVI & RAY Prosecco Spumante DOC Veneto Italy NV Silver
Sidewood Estate Sidewood Chloe Cuvée Adelaide Hills Australia 2014 Bronze
Bottega Bottega White Gold Spumante Veneto Italy NV Bronze
Prince Stirbey Spumante Extra Brut Dragasani, Oltenia Romania Bronze
Paul Mas Château Martinolles Crémant de Limoux “Grande Réserve” Languedoc France 2013 Bronze
Cave de Ribeauvillé Crémant Brut Alsace France NV Bronze
Villa Sandi Opere Serenissima Veneto Italy NV Bronze
Klein Constantia Méthode Cap Classique Constantia South Africa 2014 Bronze
£20-£30
Pongracz Desiderius Pongracz Western Cape South Africa 2011 Gold
Langlois-Chateau Crémant de Loire Prestige Cuvée ‘Quadrille’ Loire Valley France 2012 Gold
Masottina “Costabella” Brut Bio Conegliano Valdobbiadene DOCG Prosecco Superiore Veneto Italy NV Silver
Wiston Estate Brut West Sussex UK NV Silver
Masottina “Conegliano Valdobbiadene Brut” Conegliano Valdobbiadene DOCG Prosecco Superiore Veneto Italy NV Silver
Carter Estate Winery Brut Temecula Valley US 2015 Silver
SCAVI & RAY Ice Prestige Veneto Italy NV Bronze
Cono Sur Centinela Brut Casa Blanca Valley Chile 2015 Bronze
Torelló Tradicional Brut Nature Catalonia Spain 2012 Bronze
£30-£50
Pinglestone Estate Limited Louis Pommery England Hampshire UK NV Gold
Schlumberger Wein,- und Sektkellerei R. Schlumberger Grosse Reserve Poysdorf Austria 2018 Gold
Andreola Dirupo Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Spumante Brut Veneto Italy 2018 Gold
Torelló 225 Brut Nature Catalonia Spain 2015 Silver
Andreola Col del Forno Rive di Refrontolo Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Spumante Brut Veneto Italy 2018 Silver
Bird in Hand Nest Egg Joy Adelaide Hills Australia 2015 Silver
Wiston Estate Wiston Estate Blanc de Blancs Sussex England 2011 Silver
Andreola 26° Primo Rive di Col San Martino Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Spumante Brut Veneto Italy 2018 Silver
Hambledon Wineries Première Cuvée Hampshire England NV Silver
Carter Estate Winery Blanc de Blancs Temecula Valley US 2014 Silver
£50+
Gusbourne Blanc de Blancs Kent UK 2014 Gold

White Sparkling Sweet

Company Product Name Region Country Vintage Medal
Under £10
Törley Sparkling Wine Cellar Törley Excellence Sárga Muskotály Doux Hungary Hungary NV Gold
Cramele Recas Muse Stars Spumante Banat Romania NV Silver
Törley Sparkling Wine Cellar Muscosecco Sec Hungary Hungary NV Silver
Cantina Montelliana Montelliana Prosecco DOC Treviso Extra Dry Veneto Italy 2018 Bronze
Angelini Wine Angelini Prosecco DOC Treviso Extra Dry Veneto Italy 2018 Bronze
Törley Sparkling Wine Cellar Hungaria Grande Cuvée Brut Hungary Hungary NV Bronze
SC Cramele Recas Dr Spumante White Banat Romania NV Bronze
£10-£15
Lidl Ireland Allini Conegliano Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Veneto Italy 2017 Silver
Cantina Montelliana Montelliana “Meliora” Prosecco DOC Treviso Millesimato Extra Dry Veneto Italy 2018 Silver
Villa Sandi Villa Sandi Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Rive di San Pietro di Barbozza Dry Veneto Italy NV Silver
Cantina Montelliana Montelliana “57” Asolo Prosecco Superiore Veneto Italy 2018 Silver
DOCG Extra Dry Bodegas Faustino Cava Faustino Semi Seco Rioja Spain NV Bronze
Kessler Sekt Kessler Jägergrün Württemberg Germany 2017 Bronze
SCAVI & RAY Moscato Spumante Veneto Italy NV Bronze
Maccari Spumante Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Extra Dry Maccari Veneto Italy 2018 Bronze
MA Spa Vallate Prosecco DOC Extra Dry Veneto Italy NV Bronze
Maccari Spumante Prosecco DOC Extra Dry Maccari Veneto Italy 2018 Bronze
Bottega Bottega Poeti Prosecco DOCG Rive Extra Dry Prosecco Italy NV Bronze
£20-£30
Masottina “Conegliano Valdobbiadene Extra Dry” DOCG Prosecco Superiore Veneto Italy NV Silver
Masottina “Le Rive di Ogliano” Extra Dry Rive di DOCG Prosecco Superiore Veneto Italy 2017 Silver
£30-£50
Andreola Vigne dei Piai Rive di Rolle Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Spumante Dry Veneto Italy 2018 Gold
Andreola Mas de Fer Rive di Soligo Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore DOCG Spumante Extra Dry Veneto Italy 2018 Silver

Rose Sparkling Brut

Company Product Name Region Country Vintage Medal
Under £10
Alma wines S.R.L. AMBO SECCO ™ Pinot Noir Rosé Brut Lombardia Italy NV Silver
Törley Sparkling Wine Cellar Louis François & Co. Pinot Noir Rosé Brut Nature Nyerspezsgő Etyek-Buda Hungary 2014 Bronze
Viña Luis Felipe Edwards VADO Rose Colchagua Costa Chile NV Bronze
£10-£15
Pernod Ricard Winemakers Spain Gran Campo Viejo Cava Brut Rosé Cava Spain NV Silver
Cono Sur Sparkling Rosé Bio Bio Valley Chile NV Silver
Giusti Wine Rosé Spumante Brut Veneto Itay 2017 Bronze
Skull X Skinny Witch Rose Italy Italy 2018 Bronze
£15-£20
Cave de Ribeauvillé Cremant Rosé Alsace France NV Silver
£20-£30
Matahiwi Estate Matahiwi Brut Rosé Wairarapa NZ NV Gold
Bottega Rose Gold Veneto Italy NV Silver
Costaripa Mattia Vezzola Brut Rosé Lombardy Italy NV Silver
Sidewood Estate Isabella Rosé Adelaide Hills Australia 2014 Silver

Red Sparkling Sweet

Company Product Name Region Country Vintage Medal
Under £10
Törley Sparkling Wine Cellar Hungaria Rosé Extra Dry Hungary Hungary NV Silver
Masottina Masottina Cuvée Rosé Extra Dry Veneto Italy NV Bronze
Freixenet Copestick I Heart Italian Sparkling Rosé Italy Italy NV Bronze
Cramele Recas Dr Spumante Roze Banat Romania NV Bronze
Casa Vinicola Bosco Malera Rosato Spumante – Bosco dei Cirmioli Veneto Italy NV Bronze
£10-£15
Freixenet Copestick Freixenet Italian Sparkling Rosé Sant Sadurni d’Anoia Spain NV Silver

Red Sparkling Brut

Company Product Name Region Country Vintage Medal
£20-£30
Klau Estates Sparkling Shiraz South Australia Australia NV Silver

What did the judges think?

Antony Moss MW
“The tasting reinforced many impressions, such as the fact that a lot of easy pleasure can be found with Prosecco; Cava continues to go through a bumpy phase, maybe finding a new niche, but maybe fragmenting into various sub-categories of Spanish sparkling; and there are some lovely wines from the UK, but the high acidity levels do not appeal to everyone. “I was especially impressed by the entries from France – the various crémant wines. Right now, I’d say crémants offer arguably the best value for money in the sparkling category. The potential has always been there in theory, but there were many wines that were really lovely, showing pure fruit and a touch of autolytic complexity. This will affect my own buying habits.”

Michelle Cherutti-Kowal MW
“Prosecco DOC – for sub £10 – and Prosecco DOCG in the £10-£15 category were the most consistent wines, in most cases scoring a medal. It just shows that the consumer can have confidence when purchasing that type of wine. “Traditional-method sparkling wines struggled to stand out at the lower price range, although there were a few surprises from France, specifically from the Loire Valley. “At higher prices, there were some interesting and high-scoring wines from native grapes from Hungary and Austria, both which provided good alternatives for those adventurous consumers seeking out aromatic fizz styles. English sparkling, New Zealand and South Africa also had some outstanding examples. In general the wines were well made with very few poor examples. It was a lovely tasting.”

Patricia Stefanowicz MW
“The inexpensive white sparklings, mostly Prosecco, were really rather nice. These under-£10 wines seemed best when dry or nearly dry with balanced alcohol and sufficient acidity. Easy-going, crowd-pleasing wines. At £10-£15 there were some expressive crémants from the Loire, whether pure Chenin or blends made up of Chenin and Chardonnay. “Above £15, the wines performed well, many garnering good Bronze and Silver medals and a sprinkling of Golds. Interestingly, at stratospheric prices (above £30) there were a few stunning wines from England, and one from Austria. “The entrants in the Rosé Brut category were really consistent in terms of quality, with almost all the wines garnering a medal. A lovely Rosé Brut sparkling from New Zealand justified its award, a balanced wine with beautiful red fruits and just enough fresh yeast to give interest on the nose and breadth on the palate. “A mildly disappointing aspect of the tasting was the inconsistency of White Brut sparklings below £30, and in the different regions. There were very few disasters, but price didn’t necessarily correspond to quality. Caveat emptor.”

About the competition

The Global Sparkling Masters is a competition created and run by the drinks business, and is an extension of its successful Masters series for grape varieties such as Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, as well as regions such as Rioja and Champagne.

The competition is exclusively for sparkling wine, and the entries were judged using Schott Zwiesel Cru Classic glasses supplied by Wine Sorted.

The top wines were awarded Gold, Silver or Bronze medals according to their result, and those expressions that stood out as being outstanding received the ultimate accolade – the title of Sparkling Master.

The entries were judged on 19 September at Aquavit restaurant in St. James’s, London.

This report features the medal-winners only.

Please visit The Global Masters website for more information, or, to enter future competitions – giving you the chance to feature online and in print – please call +44 (0) 20 7803 2420 or email Sophie Raichura at: sophie@thedrinksbusiness.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

It looks like you're in Asia, would you like to be redirected to the Drinks Business Asia edition?

Yes, take me to the Asia edition No