This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.
Trump fires warning shot at French wine trade
US President Donald Trump has ignited a spat between the US and France by criticising France for its tariffs on US wine imports, which he claims are preventing US producers from selling their wines in France.
Following a contentious diplomatic trip to France, Trump fired off a series of tweets criticising French President Emmanuel Macron, mocking his suggestion of a European army and pointing out his low approval rating, before ending with a “Make France Great Again” jab at the nation.
He also raised the issue of tariffs on wines sold between the two countries, branding the current situation “not fair”.
“On Trade, France makes excellent wine, but so does the U.S,” Trump tweeted. “The problem is that France makes it very hard for the U.S. to sell its wines into France, and charges big Tariffs, whereas the U.S. makes it easy for French wines, and charges very small Tariffs. Not fair, must change!”
The US is currently the biggest export market for French wines, however the US imports very little wine into France. EU import duties on wine are higher than those imposed by the US.
However his comments were met with derision by many in the wine trade, including prominent US wine journalists, and bafflement by politicians in France that have been vocal supporters of Trump.
Responding to the tweet, Eric Asimov, wine critic for the New York Times, pointed out that the French may not be buying much American wine, “but it’s not because of high tariffs”.
“European wine regions have a centuries old practice of drinking local wines,” he tweeted. “This is heritage but it is slowly evolving. Still, it’s rare that anybody in Sicily will drink Tuscan wine and vice versa. You don’t see much Bordeaux in Burgundy, though you do see Burgundy in Bordeaux more and more. It’s a matter of tradition and of taste more than tariffs.”
As reported by The Guardian, the Rassemblement National (National Rally), Marine Le Pen’s far-right party, which had previously approved Trump, also criticised the US president over the attack.
Gilbert Collard, a politician who supported Le Pen’s party, said that although he felt Trump was “absolutely right” in all his attacks on Macron, he was “absolutely wrong on what he says about French wine”.
Trump has already started a trade war with China, having imposed tariffs on $50 billion worth of Chinese imports into America. In retaliation, China announced a counter tariff on a raft of products imported by the US into China, including a 25% hike on American whiskey, and a 15% hike on American wine imports.
It was the latest in a line of protectionist measures imposed by Trump since taking office, designed to prioritise domestic production over imported goods.
The French may not be buying much American wine, but it’s not because of high tariffs. https://t.co/lk9GRrkm6K
— Eric Asimov (@EricAsimov) November 13, 2018
European wine regions have a centuries old practice of drinking local wines. This is heritage but it is slowly evolving. Still, it’s rare that anybody in Sicily will drink Tuscan wine and vice versa. You don’t see much Bordeaux in Burgundy …1/2 https://t.co/lk9GRrkm6K
— Eric Asimov (@EricAsimov) November 13, 2018
…though you do see Burgundy in Bordeaux more and more. It’s a matter of tradition and of taste more than tariffs. 2/2 https://t.co/lk9GRrkm6K
— Eric Asimov (@EricAsimov) November 13, 2018
You may ask, who is selling most of the wines in France? Answer: The supermarkets/discount chains stand for about 8o % of all wine sales. They carry in their shelfes wines from all French regions and the hypermarkets even a small shelf with “vins etrangers”, wines from other countries, also a few from California. So foreigen wines have not a great chance to get listed from the
chains and are not promoted. It is not so much a problem with the tariffs, but more with the attitude of the winebuyers, who believe that French People shall drink French wines only….
Mikel
Asimof should climb down off his perch and walk through the real world. Since the power growth of the EU the CCT, for Mr Asimof’s benefit, the Common Community Tariff , has been deliberately adjusted by the EU in accordance with those countries outside their corrupt union , for the financial benefit of themselves. Trump knows this as does every exporter of non EU wines into this European disaster zone.
First Mr Trump should know that the tariffs he talks about are for all the EEC countries.
They have been established over 20 years ago in the CMO and no country decides in itself!!!
“The US is currently the biggest export market for French wines, however the US imports very little wine into France.” Ha ha, I think we all know why that is!